News Section Logo NEWS - Return to news section


Joel Tenenbaum RIAA Damages Increased Back To $675,000

Posted by: , 13:31 AEST, Tue September 20, 2011

Permanent Link     Add Comments
submit to reddit
Joel Tenenbaum has to pay the RIAA $675,000 as the RIAA wins their appeal of an earlier ruling which saw the penalty reduced to $67,500

The world's second most famous music pirate, Joel Tenenbaum, has faced a minor setback this week after the appellate court rejected Judge Nancy Gertner's earlier ruling which reduced the amount of damages Tenenbaum owes to $67,500. But it's not all bad news for the Boston University student.

The RIAA has appealed Judge Gertner's assertions that the original jury awarded damages amount of $675,000 was "unconstitutional". And while it appears the RIAA were successful, the ruling of the First Circuit Court of Appeals suggests that the appeal success was more of a technical victory, than a legal one.

The appeals court felt that Judge Gertner should not have brought up the Constitutional question before using the more appropriate remittitur order. Remittitur would still allow the judge to lower the damages amount, give the RIAA the option to accept the amount, or reject it and seek a new trial, at which time, it would have then been more appropriate to bring up the constitutional issues.

What this means now though is that both parties will have to go back to court and let everything play out, just like Thomas-Rasset case, in which remittitur was also used, rejected, and the constitutional issue was brought up (which has since been appealed again by the RIAA).

But once this case gets to the stage where the constitutional issues are in play, it does look good that any RIAA appeal would at time be rejected based on statements the appeals court have made in relation to this current appeal. The appeals court stated they also felt that the penalties being handed out was harsh. "We comment that this case raises concerns about application of the Copyright Act which Congress may wish to examine," wrote the judges in their summary.



Related News:

News Icon Jammie Thomas-Rasset RIAA Damages Reduced By $1.45m

posted by: Jason F, 17:16 AEST, Tue July 26, 2011

News Icon MP3tunes Wins, and Loses, Copyright Case Against EMI

posted by: Jason F, 17:12 AEST, Tue August 23, 2011

News Icon The End May Be Near For Righthaven's "Copyright Trolling"

posted by: Jason F, 16:07 AEST, Fri September 9, 2011

News Icon 20,000 New Users Added To Hurt Locker Lawsuit

posted by: Jason F, 16:32 AEST, Thu May 26, 2011

News Icon MPAA Piracy Stats Pulled Apart - Every Pirate Would Buy 100 DVDs

posted by: Sean F, 14:32 AEST, Thu September 8, 2011