News Section Logo NEWS - Return to news section


New Study: Nearly One Third of Takedown Requests 'Questionable'

Posted by: , 11:43 AEST, Sun April 3, 2016

Permanent Link     Add Comments
submit to reddit
New research suggests a high percentage of DMCA takedown requests may be invalid
News story feature image
Image/Photo Credit: Horia Varlan @ Flickr, CC

A new study shows that 28% of piracy takedown requests submitted to Google may be questionable at best.

The study by researches at Columbia University's American Assembly and Berkeley's School of Law looked at more than 108 million takedown requests submitted to the search engine, and found that a large percentage of these may be invalid.

4.2% of these requests targeted content that wasn't even present on the listed URLs, while another 24% raised issues about the request's validity, including in relation to fair use.

Some also targeted websites that no longer existed, such as the now shuttered

Rights-holders themselves usually aren't involved in the actual process of locating infringing links. Instead, they outsource the job to companies that specialize in anti-piracy activities. These companies will normally use automated scripts to scour the web for potentially infringing links, but these automated "bots" are prone to false positives.

Worse yet, when these links are submitted to Google, Google's uses their own bots to determine the validity of the request, meaning the entire process could be devoid of human intervention and verification. The researchers also say Google, like many other service providers, takes a cautions approach when it comes to removal requests and often over removes content just to protect themselves legally.

This, the researchers say, is why calls for a "take down, stay down" regime are potentially very dangerous, with many legitimate sites likely to be wrongly targeted.


Related News:

News Icon British Music Copyright Group Wants 'Take Down, Stay Down' Google Policy

posted by: Sean F, 18:21 AEDT, Mon March 28, 2016

News Icon Google Facing 1,500 Piracy Takedown Requests per Minute

posted by: Sean F, 12:09 AEDT, Wed December 2, 2015

News Icon EFF Warns against Calls for 'Filter-Everything' Approach

posted by: Sean F, 18:36 AEDT, Mon January 25, 2016

News Icon Spammers Abusing Google's DMCA System

posted by: Sean F, 16:52 AEST, Wed September 23, 2015

News Icon Australian Parliament Passes Anti-Piracy Web Censorship Bill

posted by: Sean F, 12:26 AEST, Thu June 25, 2015