Archive for November, 2007

PS3: A week later …

Friday, November 30th, 2007

PlayStation 3As promised, this blog post will talk a little about my experience with buying the PS3, setting it all up, and the experience of my first week of using it. Regular readers will know that I already own a Wii and a 360, so gaming wise, I’m pretty covered already. Therefore, my main purpose for the PS3 remain video playback, in particular, Blu-ray playback. Before this, I was format neutral in spirit, but HD DVD only in practice. Getting a Blu-ray player, and the PS3 being one of the cheaper ones (despite being one of the best players, certainly the most upgradable and future proof), was therefore the next logical step.

I live in Australia. Melbourne to be exact. And even though the Australian dollar is at an all time high (or thereabouts), our PS3s are still overpriced – we pay dearly to subsidized people in the US, it seems. Before I buy anything, I always do a quick search online to see if there are any bargains to pick up. I stumbled upon DTV Forum Australia, a forum I have visited on and off in the past. There was a thread in there about PS3 bargains, and from the thread I found an offer for a standard PS3 40 GB with wireless controller, plus the Sony Blu-ray remote and a redemption offer for 3 Blu-ray movies (Casino Royale, Ghost Rider and Spider-Man 3), all for $11 less then the recommended retail price (RRP is $699, or $USD 620 – I told you our PS3 was overpriced). This was the best deal I could find, and so I decided to go shopping.

Joytech TriLink HDMI SwitchBut before I went, I decided to make a list of the things I will need to get the PS3 Blu-ray up and running (I don’t like pen and paper, so a mental list it was). The first is an HDMI cable, which the PS3 package does not include unfortunately – even the component cable is sold separately, which is a bit cheap on Sony’s part I might say, especially when we’re paying $220 more than our US counterparts). But since the single HDMI connector on my TV was already being used, and my AV receiver does not support HDMI, the only solution is to get a HDMI switch. I decided on the Joytech HDMI TriLink. And this of course meant getting a second HDMI cable. And unlike the US package, our PS3 package does not include a movie in the box, so I will have to get a Blu-ray movie to test the damn thing, since I did not want to wait 6 to 8 weeks for my free movies to arrive. And I almost forgot that I also needed an Ethernet cable, since the PS3 doesn’t include one of these either (but to be fair, it does include wireless network support). And I really did forget that I also needed an optical audio cable, but luckily I added it to my mental list before I set off to do the shopping. The PS3 might be a cheap-ish Blu-ray player (by our standards), but the needed accessories makes it not so cheap after all.

Buying the PS3 went somewhat smoothly. The hardest part was getting the huge box to the car, which was parked some distance away. The Xbox 360 box was large, but manageable. This PS3 box was much bigger than I had expected, and much heavier too. While the salesman was himself struggling to get the box from the back of the store to me, I had a look at the “Buy 2 get 1 free” offer they had for Blu-ray movies. In Australia, our Blu-ray and HD DVD movie prices are outrageous as well – usually $USD 35 per movie ($30 if you’re lucky). The movies in the B2G1F stand was even more outrageously priced, at $USD 45 per movie. No thanks. I will have to go to another store to get my Blu-ray movie, which I had to go to anyway for the other accessories.

So to the other store I went, and my credit card was taking a pounding by this point. And remembering a mental list when you’re carrying 5 KG boxes the size of a small car is not recommended – at one point, I had to go back to the same store twice because I had forgotten to get a few things, the second time I almost forgot another item (the optical cable again). For the record, I purchased Rocky Balboa on Blu-ray because I was interested in its AVC H.264 encoding, and also because I haven’t seen the movie before. Here’s the list of damages at the end of the day (in Australian dollars):

MoneyPS3 – $688
Rocky Balboa Blu-ray: $40
Joytech TriLink: $60
2 x HDMI cables: $60
1 x Ethernet cable: $10
1 x Toslink cable: $20

So all together, that’s $878, which translates to nearly $USD 780. If I was in the US, the whole package probably won’t cost me more than $500, $550 at most. Oh well.

The wallet bashing was over, time to get home and set it up. It wasn’t too hard, to be honest, other than the fact that I have far too many cables already going everywhere, and having more cables did not help. The PS3 setup was pretty easy, setup the HDMI output, set up the optical audio and that’s it. What took a long time was inputting the usernames, sign up details and downloading the updates, but all the consoles are like that these days.

For the past week, I’ve been testing the PS3’s video playback functions, mainly to help me write the PS3 H.264 Conversion Guide (which I’ve updated today to add instructions on how to get AC3 5.1 audio tracks, with some trickery involving MKV to VOB conversion). I’m very impressed with both Blu-ray and the upscaled DVD playback, and if not for the fact that the PS3 is not region free for either of these formats (DVD in particular), I would make it my primary disc player. But as such, my existing region-free upscaling DVD player will still have to occupy a space on the home theatre rack. In between video tests, I’ve been running the Folding@Home software to help contribute some work units to our team.

My TV (Pioneer PDP-504) has what Pioneer calls PureCinema Advanced, which is just 3:3 pulldown (24 FPS -> 72 Hz) for smooth film playback. For whatever reason, I can’t get it to work over component without glitches, but over HDMI, it works a treat. Watching a Blu-ray movie with this option turned on is really fantastic – smooth pans that you don’t see with 3:2 pulldown. I know some people hate PAL speedup, but I find it much more acceptable than 3:2 judder. Now I’ll have to go about upgrading my Xbox 360 to a HDMI capable (and quieter) model, to make HD DVD viewing just as nice.

AVCHD LogoThe next thing I want to try is to make my own AVCHD disc to play on the PS3. AVCHD is basically a mini-Blu-ray, supporting H.264 video and AC3 audio. Nero Vision supports making these types of discs, but there’s still a couple of things I need to figure out. If/When I do, I’ll write a guide for it.

So that’s my first week with the PS3. I’ve done some work, enjoyed some movies and helped out a good cause by donating the free processing power, so all in all, it’s been a good week. PS3 for upscaled DVD and Blu-ray playback is highly recommended.

H.264 on PlayStation 3 – guide now available

Tuesday, November 27th, 2007

After finally getting a PS3 last week, I got around yesterday to start testing the playback of H.264 files on the PS3, and today, I finished writing a guide for it. It is very much based on the Xbox 360 version of the guide, but with a few added things like AAC 5.1 audio, which the PS3 supports (sort of). Guide linky below:

PS3 H.264 Conversion Guide

The playback quality is excellent, and it’s fun watching the bitrate display show just how variable the bitrate is during playback. If you have an AV receiver that supports AAC decoding, or one that has HDMI input and supports PCM 5.1 audio, then you will be able to enjoy 5.1 channel audio as well.

If you don’t have any H.264 files to test playback, you can download some from our movies section – the ones marked “Xbox 360 compatible” will be PS3 compatible too.

More on my initial PS3 experiences later this week …

Update: A new version of the guide has been release, and it now includes instructions on how to get AC3 5.1 audio for those that don’t have AAC decoders. It uses MeGUI to make a MKV file, and then uses a tool called mkv2vob to remux it into a VOB file. Don’t ask me why, but it works and the PS3 plays it perfectly, even though VOB files are not designed to hold H.264 video.

Weekly News Roundup (25 November 2007)

Sunday, November 25th, 2007

Time again for the weekly news roundup. I’ve been fairly busy this week with a few things like looking up Blu-ray and HD DVD bargains and posting them in the blog and forum, and while I’ve been advocating HD format neutrality right here for a while now, I’ve finally made myself format neutral by buying a PS3. I will post more about my shopping experiences and my initial experiences with the PS3 in this blog later this week.

Starting with Copyright news as usual, Macrovision, the company responsible for screwing up the video signal if you did not plug it straight to the TV, has now purchased the recently hacked/bypassed BD+ copy protection system for Blu-ray in a deal worth $45 million (so that’s how much a cracked copy protection system is worth!). With DRM at an all time low in terms of popularity, it must be a big worry for companies like Macrovision which relies on the “need” for DRM for a profit. Kim Bayley, director-general of the UK based Entertainment Retailers Association says that DRM is “stifling growth and working against the consumer interest”, and I think she’s right. DRM-Free MP3s are selling very well indeed, and I don’t think music piracy has increased due to these easily copyable music files. But while the world seems to be united in fighting DRM and restrictive copyright legislation, France’s newly elected (US commercial interest friendly) right wing government wants to set up a new body which will monitor Internet usage. ISPs will monitor the activities of their users and report to the body, and if someone is found guilty of piracy, they could be banned from using the Internet. This sounds more like a fight against privacy than a fight against piracy, in my opinion. And it’s not just the French, the MPAA wants universities to help stop piracy by monitoring the Internet usages of their students through a toolkit provided by the MPAA. So governments spying on citizens, ISPs spying on its customers, school spying on their students … is it me, or does this all sound very Orwellian. Meanwhile, Hollywood is making record profits, while not paying it’s writers what they deserve forcing them to go on strike. It’s all about the money.

Onto something a bit less frightening now. In HD news, Home Media Magazine has written a story about the HD format war and the fan’s contribution to it. It’s a very interesting read, not just because I’m quoted in it, but it summarises what is going on in forums and on websites, and how the war seems to be slightly out of control at times. And the two promotion groups for the formats are not exactly helping, coming out all the time with misleading statements and fuel to add to the fire. This time, it’s Blu-ray with a series of viral ads that they’ve been trying to get websites to promote. But these ads are quite childish, petty and not all that funny (apart a scene where Betamax player is seen being thrown away into the “junk closet”, perhaps as a reminder of the fortune of Sony’s last proprietary format), and it certainly doesn’t help calm the two sides of the format war. Sometimes it’s hard to not get caught up in it (although as I mentioned above, I’m now format neutral), but in the end people love movies, not formats. But the war does bring some benefits, and there are lots of bargins to pick up during the holiday sales period. The latest one sees Wal-Mart offering the 80 GB PS3 plus 10 Blu-ray movies (worth $30 or less), plus the existing 5 free movie redemption from Sony, for only $499. It was 2 per store only, and it’s over now as it only lasted one day, but I doubt that it will be the last of the sales. Keep you eyes peeled for bargains, and just like I’ve done for the past week, I’ll be posting some of the best online offers here in this blog.

Onto gaming, in an effort to bring more developers to the Sony stable, they have now halved the price of PS3 development kits. It’s a step in the right direction, although if they truly want the PS3 to be a successful games platform, they need to do a lot more. For my new PS3, I’m going to be using it more as a upscaling DVD and Blu-ray players, rather than a games machine, which is not what Sony wants (since they lose money on each console sold). I will talk more about this later in the week, but let’s just say that my Xbox 360 and Wii, plus the good old PC, provides for all my gaming needs without the need for the PS3. But it is an excellent Blu-ray and upscaling DVD players, and even if you use it just for these functions, the price is still not too bad compared to standalones. Meanwhile, somebody has leaked the Xbox 360 Fall update list, but I’m highly suspicious of it’s legitimacy, let’s put it this way. The PS3 has also been updated again with the 2.01 firmware to fix a few issues in the 2.00 firmware. The speculation is that the PS3 will get Blu-ray 1.1 profile compatibility before the start of the new year, as that’s why Sony will release its first 1.1 movie. Another week, and another report of a multi-platform release that rocks on the 360 and sucks on the PS3 – this time for the excellently valued Orange Box collection. The developers Valve apparently decided to concentrate on the 360 version, and dumped the PS3 development on publishers EA. I know PS3 fanboys will scream at Valve for being “lazy”, but all these companies have limited resources and if the decision is between making two average versions, or concentrating on getting at least one version right, I think they have done the same thing. The alternative is to have a further 6 to 12 month delay for the PS3 version to get everything right, but I’m fanboys will be even more outraged if this had happened. It seems that the PS3 is not doing well at all in the gaming department, but if you look at the yearly sales figures for all the consoles, it’s not doing too badly. But just like with HD stuff, the console wars will bring discounts over the coming weeks. For example, this last friday, dubbed Black Friday in the US, Amazon ran some sales which saw heavy discounts for several gaming items. Again, I will post some of the better online deals when I see them.

See you in a week’s time.

New Amazon 3-For-2 Blu-ray/HD DVD deal – Updated

Friday, November 23rd, 2007

28 November Update: Both sales are now over.  

26 November Update: The original 3 for 2 sale has now ended, but Amazon has a new one with fewer titles than the original. See, I told you to be quick. Oh well, the “new” sale is better than nothing I suppose. And just in case you still don’t want to heed my advice to be quick, the Blu-ray sale is specifically listed as a one day only sale, so there’s no if and buts about how quickly this one will end. The links below have been updated.

Amazon has launched a new Buy 2 get 1 free deal (3 for the price of 2) for selected Blu-ray and HD DVD titles. It’s not as good as your classic BOGO (Buy One Get One) free deal, but it’s better than nothing, especially for HD DVD fans. You better be quick though, because the last B2G1F deal for HD DVD only lasted a couple of days before it was abruptly ended.

Here are the links:

Buy Two Blu-ray Discs and Receive a Third for Free

Buy Two HD DVDs and Receive a Third for Free

As mentioned before, get them while they are still available because judging by past sales, they go pretty quickly.

Lowest Ever Priced Blu-ray Player @ Amazon!

Thursday, November 22nd, 2007

Samsung BD-P1400

Amazon has dropped the price of the Samsung BD-P1400 to the lowest ever recorded for a Blu-ray player at $339.99. The BD-P1400, a Profile 1.0 player, is the first player to feature DTS-HD Master Audio (through a recent firmware update). While $339.99, which includes 5 free Blu-ray movies from a choice of 18, represents the best ever value for a Blu-ray player so far, it is still somewhat more expensive than the cheapest HD DVD player. Even not including the $99 sale earlier this month, the Toshiba HD-A3 can be had at Amazon right now for only $187.04 plus 10 free HD DVD movies (or is that $187.04 for 10 HD DVD movies, and get the HD-A3 for free?). Either way, the format war does have it’s advantages in helping bring down hardware prices and for the increasing number of free goodies being bundled. And with the holiday sales on, it might just be a great time to get into HD (both Blu-Ray and HD DVD) right now.