News Section Logo NEWS - Return to news section


YouTube Downloading Service Sued For Copyright Infringement

Posted by: , 14:10 AEST, Sat August 27, 2011

Permanent Link     Add Comments
submit to reddit
Everyone has done it. Downloading YouTube videos seems to be no different to time-shifting on TiVo or DVRs, but it seems the major music labels are not happy people are doing it, and have sued downloader website TubeFire

In what appears to be a new target for music labels, TubeFire, a website that allows users to download YouTube videos, has been sued in Japan by the four majors, Universal, EMI, Sony, Warner, and 25 other labels.

TubeFire operates in the same way as dozens of other 'YouTube downloader' websites, in that it extracts the raw video stream from YouTube videos, and then packages it in a downloadable format, like FLV or MP4. Not only are there websites, there are also extension and add-ons for browsers that do exactly the same. These services have existed for many years without attracting any legal attention, as a lot of these services are nothing more than URL rewriting.

But TubeFire may have been targeted to be made an example of in this test case, where the music labels are concerned people are downloading music videos and songs from officially uploaded YouTube clips, even though in most cases, the audio quality is not comparable to freely available pirated MP3s. 

The labels are suing TubeFire for $3 million in damages and also the closure of the website. TubeFire has temporarily suspended their service as a precaution.

It is unknown if the music labels, represented by the RIAA in the United States, plans to file similar lawsuits against websites and software publishers offering similar services.

Do you think it should be illegal to download streaming content, even if it's just a URL rewrite and no DRM has been broken in the process? Post your opinion in this news article's comments section, or in this forum thread:


Related News:

News Icon Dead Person Sued For Copyright Infringement, While 'The Expendables' Lawsuits Dropped

posted by: Sean F, 13:54 AEST, Sat August 27, 2011

News Icon CNET Sued For Hosting LimeWire Software

posted by: Sean F, 13:46 AEST, Thu May 5, 2011

News Icon isoHunt Sued Again, This Time By The Record Companies

posted by: Sean F, 17:27 AEDT, Tue February 15, 2011

News Icon LimeWire Reaches $105m Settlement With Record Labels

posted by: Sean F, 20:48 AEST, Fri May 13, 2011

News Icon MPAA Succeeds In Forcing ISP To Block Alleged Piracy Websites

posted by: Sean F, 17:08 AEST, Sat July 30, 2011