News Section Logo NEWS - Return to news section


Good News and Bad News for Sued-By-MPAA Hotfile

Posted by: , 00:16 AEST, Wed July 13, 2011

Permanent Link     Add Comments
submit to reddit
Hotfile has received both good news, and bad news, in their fight against the MPAA over copyright infringement claims

The Motion Picture Association of America's (MPAA) case against file host Hotfile has had an important update, and it's both good news, and bad news, for Hotfile.

The good news for the "digital locker" website is that the judge in the case has thrown out the "Direct Copyright Infringement" claim of the MPAA's lawsuit, ruling that it is Hotfile's users that do are the infringers, not Hotfile. Hotfile has always claimed they're only operating as a service provider, and if any infringing material is uploaded, it is done so by end users, without the company's specific authorization. Hotfile claims that because they don't operate a search service for the uploaded files on their website, they're not actively allowing people to find files without being informed by the original uploader, or via a third party tool. The MPAA contends that Hotfile knowingly relies upon pirates to maintain indexes or pirated files hosted on Hotfile.

The bad news is that the judge decided that the MPAA's claim of "Secondary Copyright Infringement" will go ahead to a trial. The MPAA claims that Hotfile both induced its users to commit copyright infringement, and profited from it. Hotfile operates an affiliate program in which uploaders of the most popular files receive monetary rewards. And as files uploaded by users are available publicly (as long as the URL is known), this kind of mass, public sharing, might make it very difficult for Hotfile to fight charges and they are not guilty of secondary copyright infringement. 

The case continues.

How do you think this case will play out? An easy MPAA win, or will Hotfile succesfully defend themselves? Post your answer in this news article's comments section, or in this forum thread:


Related News:

News Icon MPAA Sues Hotfile, Claims Hotfile Encourages Users To Pirate

posted by: Sean F, 13:49 AEDT, Wed February 9, 2011

News Icon Googles Wades Into Fellow Search Engine isoHunt's Trial ... On The MPAA's Side

posted by: Sean F, 17:03 AEDT, Tue February 22, 2011

News Icon Google Stands Up To Proposed New Copyright Laws, Will Fight It All The Way

posted by: Sean F, 16:31 AEST, Thu May 19, 2011

News Icon Studios Wants To Ban Newzbin via ISP Filter, Wants To "Murder" Hotfile

posted by: Sean F, 17:35 AEST, Wed June 29, 2011

News Icon CNET Piracy Lawsuit Dismissed, But CNET Not Celebrating

posted by: Sean F, 17:42 AEST, Wed July 6, 2011