News Section Logo NEWS - Return to news section


New Senate Proposal: Five Years In Jail For Embedding YouTube Videos

Posted by: , 00:10 AEST, Sun June 5, 2011

Permanent Link     Add Comments
submit to reddit
You could go to jail for 5 years if you link to or embed the wrong YouTube video, if a new senate bill is passed

A new bill being proposed in the US Senate could see people sent to prison for 5 years for the simple act of embedding a YouTube video.

Senators Amy Klobuchar, John Cornyn and Christopher Coons proposed changes to the law that would "harmonize" the civil and criminal sections of the copyright act. Currently, there are no criminal sanctions for unauthorized "performances", which is only covered by the civil side.

Unfortunately, due to vague language being used in bill in regards to the definition of "performance" that doesn't distinguish between hosting, linking and embedding, people who merely post YouTube clips may end up facing criminal sanctions.

The proposed bill then tries to define what is a felony performance, by using the rather arbitrary measurement of "10 or more public performances by electronic means, during any 180-day period". 

So in the most liberal interpretation of these proposed changes, someone embedding a YouTube clip containing unauthorized content, in a forum or on their blog, could face up to 5 years in prison if the video has been viewed more than 10 times in the last 180 days. Even if they did not upload the video in question, or were aware of the legal status of said upload. 

And while this liberal interpretation may seem like an extreme position, it actually fits in well with the government's current strategy of seizing domain names of websites that only embed or link to existing content.

Do you think these new proposed changes are too extreme? Post your opinion in this news article's comments section, or in this forum thread: 


Related News:

News Icon Anonymous Plans New Zeland Government Attack Over New Copyright Laws

posted by: Anne N, 18:37 AEST, Tue April 19, 2011

News Icon Android's YouTube Video Rentals Doesn't Like Rooted Phones

posted by: Jason F, 14:54 AEST, Wed June 1, 2011

News Icon Google Stands Up To Proposed New Copyright Laws, Will Fight It All The Way

posted by: Sean F, 16:31 AEST, Thu May 19, 2011

News Icon ICE Use Seized Domains To Spread Anti-Piracy Propaganda

posted by: Jason F, 18:23 AEST, Thu April 28, 2011

News Icon Star Wars "May The 4th" Blu-ray Event, What's It All About?

posted by: Anne N, 00:58 AEST, Thu May 5, 2011