News Section Logo NEWS - Return to news section


Startup, Tech Community Oppose Piracy Filters, Says They're Too Costly, Error Prone

Posted by: , 15:53 AEDT, Sat April 1, 2017

Permanent Link     Add Comments
submit to reddit
Piracy filters are expensive, prone to error and limited in scope, says lobby group representing tech startups
News story feature image
Image/Photo Credit: IsaacMao @ Flickr, CC

A non profit organization that represents tech startups and the general tech community has spoken out against rights-holder calls in the U.S. for piracy filters to be made mandatory for internet service providers and websites.

The non-profit, Engine, says that not only are piracy filters prone to false positives, they will also be so costly that it will hurt nascent companies and stifle innovation in the process.

"Reversing two decades of sensible copyright policy to require OSPs to deploy tools that are costly, easily circumvented, and limited in scope would deeply harm startups, users, and content creators alike," says Engine.

In Engine's report, the startup lobby group cites a recent case study which found a false positive rate of 1 to 2 percent when piracy filters are used.

This may not sound like a lot, but considering many sites deals with millions of user generated files, this could lead to tens of thousands legitimate files being filtered for no reason.

"Accordingly, a 1–2 percent false positive rate for an automated filtering procedure is problematic for the same reasons, as such a technique would result in filtering legitimate content at rates that would frequently obstruct speech," Engine's report states.

Engine also estimates the cost of implementing a filter for a medium sized file sharing service would be $10,000 and $25,000 in licensing fees alone, something that will be out of reach for smaller startups.

So an mandatory filter could end up being an expensive foible that's prone to false positives could also be easily made redundant, with new file formats escaping the filter's attention, and it would also not stop sites outside of the U.S. not beholden to the country's copyright laws from offering pirated files.

[via TorrentFreak]


Related News:

News Icon Cisco Working on Automated Piracy Stream Shutdown Tool

posted by: Sean F, 19:11 AEDT, Thu October 27, 2016

News Icon Google, Bing Anti-Piracy Agreement: 'Neutral' Searches, Domain Hopping Addressed

posted by: Sean F, 13:24 AEDT, Sun March 12, 2017

News Icon Pro Copyright Group Says DMCA Abuse Protesters Are Like 'Zombies'

posted by: Sean F, 13:06 AEST, Tue April 12, 2016

News Icon Critics Say US Government Got Piracy List 'Notoriously' Wrong

posted by: Sean F, 14:46 AEDT, Tue December 27, 2016

News Icon Australian Government's Advisors: Copyright Laws Favor Rights-holders Too Much

posted by: Sean F, 21:06 AEST, Thu May 5, 2016