![\"Copyright\"](\"http:\/\/www.digital-digest.com\/blog\/DVDGuy\/wp-content\/uploads\/2008\/04\/copyright.gif\" "\\"Copyright\\"")
<\/p>\nAnother short one this week, as it has been a pretty boring week in terms of news. I guess this is a kind of birthday present to me, to give me a little breather the week before. So thanks to\u00a0the MPAA, pirates, the Blu-ray people and game console companies for not making any big splashes – if you can keep it up for another week, that would be much appreciated!<\/p>\n
Here’s the news that we did get ….<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
![\"MovieSwap](\"http:\/\/www.digital-digest.com\/blog\/DVDGuy\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/03\/movieswap_player.jpg\")
<\/a>MovieSwap is a Kickstarter that wants to help you rip DVDs and share it with other people … the MPAA are not pleased<\/p><\/div>\n
A new Kickstarter aims to take DVD lending and swapping to the next level, but unfortunately, it may be a level that’s swarming with MPAA lawyers and an end boss that’s impossible to defeat. MovieSwap wants you to send in your old DVDs<\/a>, and for every DVD you send in, you’re able to swap it for another DVD send in by another user. Except the physical DVD stays with MovieSwap, and its the ripped, digital version they you’ll be swapping around.<\/p>\n DVDs can only be “lent out” one at a time, just like with a real swap, but being digital, the movie can be watched on\u00a0a variety of devices.<\/p>\n If you’ve read this blog for some time, you’ll already\u00a0know why this innovative idea will simply never work. Not because there are technical problem with it (there might be, as it seems\u00a0there might be an imbalance between the number of available copies of DVDs people want and the DVDs they actually send in), but there definitely seems to be some legal clouds over the idea behind the service. Clouds, or perhaps a category 5 cyclone.<\/p>\n The MPAA won’t like the ripping part, that’s a given. Remember\u00a0Kaleidescape and when they tried to rip DVDs for use on a local media server (not shared with anyone but the DVD’s owner), and how\u00a0they got slapped legally for it<\/a>? And while this replicates the idea of personal lending in the digital space, this kind of replication has never been viewed upon favourably, not by the\u00a0rightsholders nor by the legal system (see Aereo<\/a>\u00a0and their replication of how\u00a0DVRs work). Then there’s the small problem of the MPAA not getting even a small cut of the profits.<\/p>\n The problem for me is that MovieSwap doesn’t just replicate how DVD swapping works – it improves it by way too much.\u00a0In real life, I would never be able to swap movies with a total stranger\u00a0from anywhere\u00a0in the world\u00a0(and it might be weeks before I get my DVD back in real life). It’s DVD lending on steroids, and the\u00a0net effect will be\u00a0that people will spend less money to watch more movies, with money they would have otherwise given the the MPAA studios going into MovieSwap’s pockets instead via the monthly subscription fee.<\/p>\n It’s easy to see why the MPAA won’t like this, not one bit.<\/p>\n This is not what Phil Spencer meant by upgradeable Xbox Ones<\/p><\/div>\n A clarification from Phil Spencer about “upgradeable” Xbox Ones – they won’t be.\u00a0When Spencer originally talked about<\/a> upgrading the Xbox One hardware, some assumed it meant making the Xbox One more like PCs, with parts you can buy the upgrade the innards. Or at the very least,\u00a0making the Xbox One more modular so you can plug\u00a0in add-on hardware to make it more powerful. I for one always thought he meant just a new SKU with a beefier version of the Xbox One, that was still compatible with all existing Xbox One games, but had better graphics (it’s similar to the idea Sony\u00a0has for a Super PS4<\/a>).<\/p>\n Whatever the case is, you won’t be needing a “screwdriver set”, according to Spencer<\/a>.<\/p>\n<\/p>\n<\/a>